PREVIOUS RECAPS: Episode One // Episode Two // Episode Three // Episode 4 // Episode 5 // Episode Six // Episode Seven // Episode Eight // Episode 9 // Episode Ten
I’m making an attempt one thing totally different this week as a result of I truthfully don’t have the time to look at your complete episodes of this sequence in the intervening time and I don’t suppose my write-ups are gaining a lot from the limitless context.
In order we enter the Debut Idea Battle (aka: authentic songs), I’m going to look at the performances on YouTube and rank them from least to most favourite. My most favourite this week obtained a lowly “C” grade, so… yeah. Issues are fairly bleak in Boys II Planetville.
Once more, these are my private rankings — not the rankings on the present. And so they’re 95% concerning the tune itself as a result of the performances had been all effective. Nobody was a practice wreck. Nobody was a “can’t wait to look at that once more” standout.
Essential Dish (carried out by Essential Chef)
This one has creepy staging with baseball bats that had been even swung on the followers watching the efficiency in the course of the intro! If a bunch should pose and posture, no less than these guys decide to the bit and produce some drama to the schtick.
Music-wise, this can be a shout-chant affair anchored by a refrain that’s simply extra shouting. I significantly really feel dangerous for these guys’ vocal chords. This isn’t notably nice to hearken to, but it surely’s not for an absence of making an attempt. Rock guitar provides a little bit of welcome texture to the observe however in the end there’s not sufficient selection to make this fascinating. Even chanting might be compelling if delivered with sufficient totally different rhythmic constructions, however Essential Dish is solely the identical reheated leftovers again and again. I used to be exhausted by the top of it.
Grade: D+
Chains (carried out by Love Is)
Judging from YouTube views and chart efficiency, this appears to be the tune persons are latching onto most. That’s not too shocking because it exists inside followers’ beloved “horny” idea — full with a surplus of chains. The staging within the intro is definitely fairly cool.
So far as the music is taken into account, that is just about precisely what I’d count on from a tune known as “Chains.” It has that slinky, stuttering sound boy teams have leveraged for years. I’ve by no means been an enormous fan of this type as a result of it all the time seems like a tease – as if the tune is continually pulling away from its finest moments. This tends to truncate the melodic strains till we find yourself with a bunch of forgettable sing-talk. That’s the case right here and because of this I discover the tune extremely boring. The efficiency is okay, although the facility notes might’ve used extra oomph throughout the board. Finally, each the tune and efficiency go nowhere and haven’t any actual killing factors.
Grade: D+
Fortunate MACHO (carried out by 777)
“Fortunate MACHO” is a godawful tune title. If it was meant as camp I’d really adore it, however that is Okay-pop so we all know they’re severe. The introduction’s bike poses actually play as camp, however once more that’s not the intention.
Other than that, this tune and efficiency shade by numbers inside Okay-pop’s blustery, badass boy group oeuvre. The percussion skitters ahead with momentum that’s undercut by the comparatively lumbering rap. There aren’t many hooks to be discovered, as even the melodies really feel truncated and practical. For a tune with such power, it’s shocking to listen to how uninteresting every thing sounds. The observe begs for a refrain value coming again to. The fellows do nearly as good a job as might be anticipated, however the materials does them no favors.
Grade: C-
Sugar Excessive (carried out by Nyangnyang Chuchu)
This tune title screams “brilliant boy group idea with overalls” and that’s just about what we get (besides substitute the overalls with foolish hats, cat ears and lollipops). You’ve acquired to like how predictable Okay-pop has turn out to be!
It’s not that I naturally choose brilliant ideas over edgy ones. It’s simply that – at the present time – brilliant ideas are sometimes the one ones that put melody entrance and middle. I want this wasn’t the case, as a result of songs like this may also be just a little cloying at occasions. To me, Sugar Excessive seems like probably the most baseline model of this sort of observe, resting on established tropes with out bringing the rest to the desk. The melodies are fairly inert regardless of a punchy instrumental that clearly needs to push the tune in additional thrilling instructions. I just like the strummed guitar and love the bounding dance break, however total that is so weightless that it virtually disintegrates in entrance of you. The efficiency has some good moments however feels extra like generic fan service than a memorable survival present stage.
Grade: C
