‘The Twisted Story of Amanda Knox’: Reality vs Fiction

The Twisted Story of Amanda Knox could also be a dramatization of the Amanda Knox case, however most of the occasions depicted within the collection are true to the real-life story.

The eight-episode collection, which premiered on Hulu on Aug. 20, reexamines Knox’s function within the investigation of her British roommate Meredith Kercher’s homicide via her personal lens: Knox served as an government producer on the present alongside Monica Lewinsky.

“This isn’t a present concerning the worst expertise of somebody’s life,” Knox advised The New York Instances. “That is the present of an individual’s selection to seek out closure on their very own phrases and to reclaim a way of company in their very own life after that company has been stolen from them.”

Knox and then-boyfriend Raffaele Sollecito had been convicted of murdering Kercher in what police claimed was a drug-fueled satanic orgy with Ivory Coast immigrant Rudy Guede. Knox and Sollectio served 4 years in jail of their respective 26 and 25-year sentences for the crime.

Although their verdict was overturned in 2011, the acquittal was thrown out in 2013, and the case was retried, resulting in a second conviction in 2014. The Italian Supreme Courtroom exonerated each Knox and Sollecito in full in 2015 by overturning the case. (Guede’s 2008 conviction was upheld.)

Grace Van Patten, who performs Knox within the collection, hinted that new info could be revealed within the present, saying, “The present offers everybody the chance to know it extra and to kind an opinion primarily based on info, and never what they had been being fed on the time … It is new info that the general public doesn’t know — particularly in that final episode.”

However which components of the present, which releases weekly till Oct. 1, are primarily based on proof and which components are embellished for the sake of the story, if any?

ipromiseyoumedia breaks down all of the info versus fiction from the collection beneath.

Warning: Spoilers for The Twisted Story of Amanda Knox forward!

Had Knox solely been relationship Sollecito for one week on the time of Kercher’s homicide?

As depicted within the collection, Knox and Sollecito, who met at a live performance Knox attended with Kercher, had solely formally been a pair for seven days when Kercher was killed.

Regardless of not understanding her for a very long time, Sollecito refused to implicate Knox in Kercher’s homicide, regardless of the heavy strain he confronted from authorities. “(Amanda) advised me that she thinks that I’m a sort of hero, however I don’t really feel so,” he mentioned on At the moment in 2013. “I did it as a result of I do know it’s the reality. It’s the great factor to do. It’s the one approach for me.”

Had been Kercher and Knox “inseparable?”

Kercher and Knox are depicted as turning into extraordinarily shut shortly after transferring in collectively within the collection. “We had been inseparable at first,” Van Patten’s Knox narrates within the first episode. “That buzzy feeling of latest friendship, fellow traveler in a international land.”

Whereas she concedes within the collection that Kercher’s British associates “didn’t take” to her, she tells viewers that her late roommate appeared out for her.

Kercher’s British associates testified at Knox’s trial that that they had a distinct learn on the pair’s relationship.

In accordance with The Impartial, Kercher’s pal Robyn Butterworth described their interactions as uncomfortable. “I knew concerning the relationships in the home,” she claimed. “Meredith mentioned it was a bit awkward. She did not know the right way to speak to Amanda about flushing the bathroom and conserving the lavatory clear.”

Knox responded in her 2013 interview with ABC, reportedly saying, “It bothers me when folks counsel that she wasn’t my pal.”

She elaborated on their closeness in her 2013 memoir, Ready to be Heard, writing, “We had been simply attending to know one another, and I assumed we’d developed a snug familiarity in a short while.”

Addressing the lavatory incident, she wrote, “I handled Meredith as my confidante. Meredith handled me with respect and a way of humour. The one awkward interplay we had was when Meredith gently defined the restrictions of Italian plumbing.”

Was Knox extra alarmed by the human waste in the bathroom than the blood within the lavatory?

Within the present’s premiere episode, Knox arrives dwelling after an evening spent at Raffaele’s to seek out her entrance door open, specks of blood on the sink and a bloody lavatory mat.

She is just alarmed when she catches a glimpse of human feces in the bathroom, nevertheless.

This element rings true, in line with the 2016 Netflix documentary Amanda Knox, Knox assumed that one among her roommates had minimize themselves shaving, however felt fearful upon seeing the human waste. “That’s after I knew one thing was up,” she mentioned.

In a 2013 interview with Diane Sawyer, Knox mentioned that she thought-about the chance that the blood on the sink had been her personal, having not too long ago pierced her ears.

She additionally advised Sawyer that she didn’t see the blood on the lavatory rug till she was getting out of the bathe. Recalled Knox: “I assumed it was unusual.”

Did Knox’s roommate ask her to lie about smoking pot?

In The Twisted Story, investigators’ suspicions about Knox are aroused when she lies about smoking pot in her dwelling — one thing that her roommate asks her to do with a view to safeguard her job.

Knox made comparable claims in a 2025 private essay for The Atlantic. “Considered one of my roommates additionally requested me to lie—to disclaim to the police that we smoked marijuana,” she wrote. “She mentioned that they might lose their jobs if anybody discovered. So I lined for them.”

In accordance with Knox, the invention of marijuana crops within the downstairs house made investigators query her story and “marvel if I used to be conserving extra from them.”

Did Knox have a breakdown when revisiting the crime scene?

One highly effective scene in episode 2 reveals Knox having a nervous breakdown when she is taken again to the scene of the crime and requested to open the knife drawer within the kitchen to find out if any are lacking in an effort to find the homicide weapon.

Knox and lead Italian prosecutor Giuliano Mignini each spoke about this real-life second within the 2016 Netflix documentary Amanda Knox.

“It hit me abruptly and I turned hysterical,” Knox mentioned on the time.

For Mignini, the response additional implicated Knox as a legal in his thoughts. “Undoubtedly I began to suspect Amanda,” he mentioned.

Did Knox do the splits in the course of the police station?

In episode 2, Amanda is admonished by a policewoman for doing the splits within the station.

Although Knox admitted to doing the splits “as soon as,” she advised ABC that she didn’t do a cartwheel, which she was accused of by Chief Superintendent Giacinto Profazio throughout his testimony. “I by no means did a cartwheel. I did do the splits … as soon as,” she mentioned, including, “I might’ve been extra delicate to the folks round me.”

Sollecito claimed that Kercher’s English associates had been additionally “appalled” by the love Knox confirmed to her accomplice on the police station early on within the investigation in his 2012 memoir, Honor Certain: My Journey to Hell and Again with Amanda Knox — one thing he alleged additionally made him “uneasy.” “Amanda curled up on me like a koala bear,” he recalled. “Cops handed by commonly and glared at us. ‘State composti,” one shouted. Behave yourselves.”

Sollecito mentioned that after they had been advised to separate, he responded that it was “chilly” — a line his character additionally says within the collection. “Within the second, I didn’t need to make Amanda really feel worse,” he defined.

In Knox’s personal memoir, which was launched a 12 months later, she claimed that Sollecito instigated their touchy-feely habits. “I think that Raffaele thought I used to be having a breakdown,” Knox wrote. “He sat me in his lap and bounced me gently. He kissed me, made faces at me and advised me jokes, all in an effort to appease my agitation.”

Did the police strike Knox throughout their interrogation?

One of the disturbing scenes of the collection happens in episode 2, when Amanda is hit by a police officer throughout her Nov. 6, 2007, interrogation.

In accordance with Knox, the incident actually occurred. “I used to be hit on the again of the pinnacle, I used to be yelled at,” she advised Nightline in 2020.

She additionally advised the BBC in June 2024 that she was struck a number of instances. “The police threatened me with 30 years in jail, an officer slapped me thrice saying ‘Bear in mind, bear in mind,’ ” she mentioned.

Knox wrote in a 2025 essay for The Atlantic that police denied her allegations. “The police, who didn’t report the interrogation as they had been purported to, deny that I used to be hit or pressured into making these statements,” she wrote on the time.

NPR reported in 2019 that the European Courtroom of Human Rights ordered Italy to pay Knox $21,000 in damages, prices and bills for denying her proper to a lawyer whereas taking her assertion. The court docket additionally referred to as the room she had been interrogated in “an environment of intense psychological strain.”

The court docket didn’t discover that Knox was topic to inhumane therapy, nevertheless, citing “inadequate proof” to again these claims.

Did Knox recant her confession hours after signing it?

In Twisted Story, after a grueling police interrogation, Knox is seen signing an announcement wherein she confesses that she was in the home along with her boss, Patrick Lumumba, when her roommate was killed.

She wakes up on the station a couple of hours later and tries to recant her assertion, however is advised that it’s too late.

Knox wrote about how she skilled the second in actual life in her piece for The Atlantic.

“The interrogation I used to be subjected to stays probably the most terrifying expertise of my life,” she wrote. “I used to be 20 years previous, and was questioned for greater than 53 hours over a five-day interval in a language I used to be solely simply studying to talk.”

Knox continued: “I used to be berated, threatened, lied to and slapped, and ultimately, my sanity broke—I started to consider the lies the police had been telling me, and I agreed to signal statements inserting myself and one other harmless man in the home when the crime had occurred. I recanted just a few hours later, but it surely didn’t matter.”

Knox was later convicted of slander towards Lumumba. She was sentenced to 3 years in jail, however was credited for the 4 years she already served after Kercher’s preliminary homicide trial.

Did Knox and Prosecutor Mignini meet up in Italy?

The collection opens with Amanda hiding beneath a blanket behind a automotive on June 16, 2022, whereas en route to satisfy Prosecutor Giuliano Mignini, whom Knox has beforehand referred to as “a boogeyman determine” in her life. “My prosecutor,” she says within the closing strains of the primary episode.

In actual life, Knox met up with Mignini seven years after her conviction was overturned in an effort to know why he believed she was concerned in Kercher’s homicide. “I by no means got down to forgive him,” she advised ipromiseyoumedia in March 2025. “There was this deep curiosity in me to attempt to perceive this one who determined that I used to be a harmful particular person.”

Knox mentioned that his company over her life lessened upon assembly him. “He was an actual particular person,” she mentioned. “He wasn’t this darkish, darkish, legendary determine. He was an actual human being who had actual emotions and actual ideas, not a boogeyman. And as quickly as I noticed that, I might empathize with him.”

Mignini beforehand admitted to creating errors in his investigation within the 2016 Netflix documentary, although he didn’t elaborate on what these errors had been. “If they’re harmless, I hope they’re capable of overlook the struggling they’ve endured,” he mentioned of Knox and Sollecito. “In the event that they’re responsible, if earthly justice didn’t get to them, I hope they personal their guilt.”

Mignini advised The Telegraph in 2022 that he nonetheless believes Knox was current on the time of Kercher’s homicide. “We’ve got totally different concepts concerning the trial that concerned us, however now I’ve a superb opinion of her.”

He elaborated to The Solar in 2024, saying that whereas he believes Knox thinks she is telling the reality about her lack of involvement within the case, it’s as a result of she will’t recollect it.  “She doesn’t bear in mind,” he claimed.